is beyond meat healthy

The SWAP-MEAT Study, conducted by Standford University, became the first clinical trial of Beyond Meat’s plant-based products. To the comment by azure, grazing cattle is leading to the extinction of the few wild animals left in the USA, and every single thing you said about growing plants using up water and pesticides, means that great, you support everyone going vegan immediately, because it takes far more plants and water, to cycle through animals to produce food for humans than if we just ate the plants directly. Had those lands been left for grazing (not overgrazing) by buffalo or cattle, it’s likely the effects of drought would’ve been lessened. © 2010 - 2020 Harvard University. All rights reserved. Beyond Meat has come under fire for its 'processed' ingredients - but how does it compare to its meat counterparts? Or irrigation dependent crops grown in eastern OR irrigated by water from dammed rivers in the Pacific Northwest. Be part of the solution, be peaceful, be loving, be vegan. Chief Medical Editor, Harvard Health Publishing, Managing Director and Executive Editor, Harvard Health Publishing. These include Beyond Meat ®, Impossible Foods™, and other store brand versions of plant-based ground beef, hamburgers and sausage. I have been told that fetal calf blood is used in the manufacture of these “plant based” burgers. She has interviewed a huge range of people, from Prime Ministers to authors, activists, pop stars and actors, and enjoys the varied range of topics writing for PBN allows her to tackle. Beyond Meat also has pre-made burgers that you can just toss onto the grill. But some facts have already been released. Because arsenic was once used as a rice pesticide and it sticks around for a long long time (in the soil). What are the long-lasting effects of COVID-19? Always seek the advice of your healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding your medical condition. Scientists deem this as ‘statistically significant and clinically significant too’. Producing the newer, plant-based burgers requires considerably less water and generates substantially less greenhouse gas emissions compared with traditional beef burgers. “The bottom line: Meatless burgers are good for the planet, but not always good for our health” Depends on where the saturated fat these very processed burger comes from doesn’t it? To receive exclusive coupons, availability updates of our sizzling Beyond Burger and Beyond Sausage, and other news you can use, sign up below! There was an error and we couldn't process your subscription. The Impossible Burger and Beyond Meat aren't healthier. Any mention of products or services is not meant as a guarantee, endorsement, or recommendation of the products, services, or companies. Poultry-based burger alternatives, such as turkey burgers, also do not contain significant amounts of protective plant compounds. The Content is not intended to substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Sure, plant-based meat alternatives are better for the planet than meat, but a viral blog post called “ Beyond Meat Is Beyond Unhealthy ” got the internet wondering: Are they really that much healthier for our bodies? Get weekly health information and advice from the experts at Harvard Medical School. Sodium can be very high. The Content is not intended to substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The SWAP-MEAT Study was funded by an unrestricted gift from Beyond Meat. You only need to activate your account once. Cording cautions that Beyond Meat products have a health halo around them, and notes that you really should think of them like you would any other burger or sausage. Beyond Meat, as I understand it, is a plant-based meat company, it’s right in the name. Enter search terms and tap the Search button. Vitamin B12, for instance, is found primarily in animal sources, and strict vegetarians and vegans must get their intake from fortified sources. Its products are ‘made from simple ingredients derived from plants.. without GMOs, synthetically produced ingredients, antibiotics or hormones’, “[Our] products offer protein levels greater than or equal to their animal-based counterparts.”. Sure the graphic shows this, but readers might not know the connection…as a dietitian I thought you would elaborate on that? Beyond’s website claims that animal-based meats lead to a 16% increased risk of cancer and 21% increased risk of heart disease. However, let’s take a deeper look and compare it nutritionally with lean ground beef. The protein content of these newer plant-based burgers has been created to compete with beef and poultry gram for gram. Artificially sweetened drinks: No heart health advantage? Which has been demonstrated to increase LDL levels? To Launch 'Super Realistic' Vegan Chicken - Predicts Surge In Reducetarians, Debunked: Article Claims Eating Meat Is Better For Muscle Health In Old People, Proudly powered by Newspack by Automattic. And is known to be produced in environmentally destructive ways, i.e, by clear cutting/burning tropical rain forest to create fields for creating palm plantations, i.e, mono crops, that exhaust the soil. Some of us eat the odd veggie burger here and there, some of us never eat veggie burgers, and some of us eat them all the time. It used products from the company in comparing the health effects of animal meat with plant-based meat. Use the unsubscribe link in those e-mails to opt-out at any time. That means while these patties are a meat substitute, they're not necessarily a healthier meat substitute. Both plant-burgers get their protein from legumes: the Beyond Burger from pea protein, and the Impossible Burger from soy protein. If you subscribe to any of our print newsletters and have never activated your online account, please activate your account below for online access. Stretching: 35 exercises to improve flexibility and reduce pain, A Guide to Men's Health Fifty and Forward. With 23 grams of powerful proteins, this burger is packed with nutrition. As a former magazine editor, newspaper reporter, and features writer, her work has been published by The Guardian, The Huffington Post, and various regional newspapers, as well as Vegan Life magazine and Vegan Trade Journal. Plant-based burgers are not a novel concept. You should be discredited. Reliance on any information provided is solely at your own risk. This article is extremely misleading. Meatless “meat” burgers aren’t inherently healthier because of their meat-free status. This is certainly an important consideration for the well-being of our planet, but they may not be the best option for the health of our bodies. What you have written may be seen, disclosed to, or collected by third parties and may be used by others in ways we are unable to control or predict, including to contact you or otherwise be used for unauthorized or unlawful purposes. Is this correct? The current meme on social media which I am sure uses this article to support its ‘argument’ about how some veggie burgers are processed, so we should all just carry on eating animals and their secretions while the amazon burns and we run out of water and the ice caps are melting and our waterways are choking with animal manure so that whatever fish humans haven’t already killed directly will die from this and other human-caused pollution, and so on, is patently absurd, with its implicit suggestion that all vegans eat are beyond burgers. A plant based burger show works well on the digestive system, “Since diets higher in saturated fat are associated with increased rates of both heart disease and premature death”. Please discuss any options with your healthcare provider. Beyond cites that the number-one reason people eat meat alternatives isn’t for ethics or the environment but for their health. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call your healthcare provider or 911 immediately. In addition, participants lost 2lb on average during the plant-based portion of the study. Beyond Meat patties are not good for your health as they are high in saturated fats, and ate highly processed. Beans, for instance, are a good source of both zinc and iron. “[Participants] were instructed to consume more than two servings of plant protein compared with animal for eight weeks each… While keeping all other foods and beverages as similar as possible between the two phases,” says the study. Beyond Meat While the Beyond Burger is made without GMOs, soy or gluten, it still has a lengthy ingredient list. Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods are among the companies racing to tap into the massive U.S. market of meat eaters by more closely mimicking … It’s unclear why veggie burgers are constantly held to this high standard. Health experts aren't so sure. Do pro-inflammatory diets harm our health? This includes health implications such as heart attacks. This is a plus for vegetarians, because these nutrients are typically harder to come by when relying solely on foods from the plant kingdom. A new study, published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, says swapping from animal meat to vegan Beyond Meat can offer health benefits. Ethan Brown, the creator of Beyond Meat (the company that makes the Beyond Burger as well as Beyond Sausage, Beyond Beef Crumbles, and Beyond Ground Beef) told … © 2020 Copyright - Unless otherwise stated all contents of this web site are © 2020 - Plant Based News Ltd - All Rights Reserved. By clicking 'GO', you consent to Beyond Meat using your email address and postal code to receive emails about products, recipes and more. Tags: Beyond Meat, diet and nutrition, food and drink, vegetarian-friendly diet About Eat + Run Eating healthfully and staying in shape can be tough to balance. The Beyond Burger and 70% lean ground beef have exactly the same saturated fat content. Impossible Burger and Beyond Meat’s Beyond Burger are two such options. ... health and doing something good for the planet. No one eats a burger – veggie or otherwise – as a “heathy” choice. Unfortunately, in the case of the Impossible Burger, one serving contains less than 8% of the isoflavones found in one serving of whole soy foods (one serving is roughly a quarter of a block of tofu or 1 cup of soymilk). For those who eat at least some animal protein, the vitamin and mineral fortification is less of a selling point. Researchers found healthy participants experienced improvements in myriad health markets when swapping their protein from animal to plant-based meat. Those same dams provide electrical power (“clean” energy) yet are responsible for the sharp decline in salmon populations, lamphrey eels (eaten and used in other ways by PNW native Americans and other edible species that once lived in the dammed rivers. and may be amended from time to time. Both the Impossible Burger and Beyond Burger have comparable amounts, the former deriving protein mainly from soy and the later from peas and mung beans. PBN can reveal that after switching the protein, participants’ levels of LDL cholesterol dropped by an average of 10 milligrams per deciliter. Making the most of physical activity apps, Good news: Deaths due to HIV are way down, New high-resolution imaging scans approved for use in prostate cancer. They are also a significant source of sodium, particularly for those on salt-restricted diets. Hard to believe the irrigation (and pesticides) used to grow cotton and other water hungry crops in CA and elsewhere (AZ) is a better and more efficient use of water then raising cattle or buffalo on the prairies. Looking at the ingredient lists, it is clear that the Beyond Meat Burger and Impossible Burger patties are heavily processed foods. Beyond Burgers aren't necessarily less fatty or caloric than their real-meat counterparts, but that doesn't necessarily mean they're bad for you. This protection is often attributed to isoflavones, a subgroup of plant compounds called flavonoids thought to provide health benefits. They are also an important protein resource. Your use of this site is governed by Harvard University and its affiliates Terms of Use located at www.health.harvard.edu/privacy-policy The “what if we all Go Beyond” campaign aims to highlight improvement on animal welfare, health and environmental benefits of going meat-free. Since diets higher in saturated fat are associated with increased rates of both heart disease and premature death, they may not be the type to opt for if your ambitions are purely health-related. The following chart shows how the newer, meatless burgers stack up nutritionally against beef burgers, turkey burgers, and black bean burgers. Treating neuropathy: Which medication is best? Even though legumes are sourced for protein in the branded meatless options, their health benefits are somewhat blunted by the high degree of processing involved. Beyond Meat Southwest Style Strips And although the Impossible Burger has more saturated fat than ground beef, it overall has less fat in total. Researchers also found similar sodium intake and blood pressure levels between the animal-based and plant-based phases of the study. Another study found people with elevated TMAO had a 60 percent higher risk for adverse cardiovascular events. While I think CAFOs are environmentally destructive & very hard on cattle (just as some chicken farms that crowd chickens into too small areas and require that they receive continual low levels of antibiotics to increase their growth rate & not become ill from overcrowding (easy for illness to spread), I think there are parts of the world, including the US, where grazing animals (including buffalo) are the best use of the land. The study concludes: “Among generally healthy adults, contrasting plant with animal intake, while keeping all other dietary components similar… plant products improved several cardiovascular disease risk factors, including TMAO. For instance, moderate amounts of whole soy foods, like edamame (soybeans), have been linked to reduced rates of cancer. Source: Beyond Meat I believe Beyond Meat that this product is soy-free and gluten-free and that it has 20 grams of protein. And since beef and turkey has ZERO fiber and still have saturated fat, I would think plant based is HEALTHIER all around! . 300 billion animals are killed PER DAY around the world (this includes fish) for food, and all of this suffering, pollution, death and violence is completely unnecessary. Beyond Meat Keeps Nasdaq Healthy; Nikola Takes Another Hit Bullish investors don't seem willing to rest very long. Both articles and products will be searched. The SWAP-MEAT Study, conducted by Standford University, became the first clinical trial of Beyond Meat’s plant-based products. Please note: If you have a promotional code you'll be prompted to enter it prior to confirming your order. I find it depressing that the author of this article did not even mention that eating animals is barbaric and inhumane, and that this is perhaps also a great reason not to do so, especially when study after study has shown that people who eat plants and not animals have less cancer, heart disease, obesity and live longer and healthier lives, so there is no justification whatsoever to eat animals or their secretions in 2019. But are they heart healthy? Maria is the editor of Plant Based News. The information you share, including that which might otherwise be Protected Health Information, to this site is by design open to the public and is not a private, secure service. We asked nutritionists to weigh in on how they measure up to traditional beef burgers and other popular veggie burgers. This week, a look at the Beyond Burger and how it compares with beef and other meat-free options. Atrial fibrillation: Shifting strategies for early treatment? Beyond Meat had no involvement in designing or conducting the study and did not participate in data analysis. A new generation of plant-based products are taking veggie burgers to a whole new level. Black bean burgers are never going to be mistaken for hamburgers, but they are typically a solid choice when it comes to health. This is a plus for vegetarians, because these … | Proudly Powered By Newspack. Hyperemesis: (Way) beyond morning sickness, Avoid these common health perils of Thanksgiving, Parents: Call the doctor right away for these 4 symptoms, If you have low back pain try these steps first, Answer these 5 questions to help make your New…, The Harvard Medical School 6-Week Plan for Healthy Eating, Improving Memory: Understanding Age-Related Memory Loss. Is Beyond Meat healthier than meat? By clicking submit, you agree to share your email address with the Plant Based News to receive marketing and updates. Two of the most popular meat alternative companies are Impossible Burger and Beyond Burger which are available in 40,000 restaurants and grocery stores combined. goes beyond beyond italian sausage pizza, available for a limited time at pizza hut nationwide. You should think carefully before disclosing any personal information in any public forum. More in brown rice in then white. Beyond Meat may be healthy for the planet, but is it good for individual health? Factually correct, but it entirely misses the point. And can anti-inflammatory diets help? This doesn’t mean a plant-focused diet is lacking in nutrients. As with any public forum on any site, this information may also appear in third-party search engines like Google, MSN, Yahoo, etc. Impossible Burger also adds vitamins and minerals found in animal proteins — like vitamin B 12 and zinc — in amounts equal to (and in some cases, greater than) both red meat and poultry. According to the study’s authors, until now, there has been limited evidence of the health effects of plant-based alternative meats. Unless it’s been grown outside of the US or in a part of the US where arsenic based pesticides weren’t used as much. Most melanomas come in the form of a new spot on the skin, not changes to an existing mole. So, they set out to compare the effect of consuming plant-based alternatives as opposed to animal meat on health factors. Eating these burgers is touted as a strategy to save the earth, casting meat as a prehistoric concept. . What’s more, plant compounds such as phytic acid bind to minerals, which can increase requirements of zinc by 50% and may necessitate consuming about two times as much iron. Furthermore, some vegans don’t even eat the impossible burger since one of its ingredients was tested on animals. Both brands also offer up their products as nutritious alternatives to animal protein. If a lower risk of diseases like cancer and heart disease is your ultimate goal, aim for the kind of veggie burgers that showcase their beans, grains, and seeds front and center. Photo courtesy of Beyond Meat Beyond Meat announced that it's juiciest and most nutritious burgers are yet to come. Please reload the page and try again. Surely a cost, like water consumption, that needs to be considered in an analysis of the costs of growing plant foods. A new study, published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, says swapping from animal meat to vegan Beyond Meat can offer health benefits. Beyond Meat… The same can’t necessarily be said of the aforementioned beef substitutes, which have been created to mimic what many people love about a burger — the red juicy center and meaty taste. Can adopting a healthier diet help fight prostate cancer? The contents displayed within this public group(s), such as text, graphics, and other material ("Content") are intended for educational purposes only. Is The Beyond Burger Healthy for You? And Is It Healthier Than Meat? There were no adverse effects on risk factors from the plant products.”. Yes, they do contain healthy added supplements, but this is not good enough to outweigh the bad. Androgens, the family of male sex hormones that includes testosterone, function as a fuel for growth in normal development. Receive all the latest news, best updates, giveaways, discounts, product announcements, and much, much more. Impossible Burger also adds vitamins and minerals found in animal proteins — like vitamin B12 and zinc — in amounts equal to (and in some cases, greater than) both red meat and poultry. Radiation after prostate cancer surgery may not be necessary, "Awe" walks inspire more joy, less distress, Hormone therapy and radiation may help with certain prostate cancer, Unlocking the mystery of chronic pelvic pain syndrome, Irregular and long menstrual cycles linked to shorter life, Women with DCIS at increased risk for breast cancer death, A silent condition may be taking a toll on your health, Smokers may have higher risk of brain aneurysm, Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children, Healthy Eating: A guide to the new nutrition. The Beyond Meat patty and Impossible Burger are still great resources for reducing red meat consumption and introducing people to a plant-based diet, dietitian Sharon Palmer said. What if it’s palm oil? NOTHING wrong with Saturated Fat. Plant-based meat critics have previously slammed Beyond Meat over it’s ‘proccessed’ ingredients list – but is Beyond Meat healthy? Choose legume-based varieties studded with seeds and whole grains, like brown rice and quinoa. It was poor land use practices plus drought (poor practices made the effects of the drought worse, just as farming practices made the late 1800’s drought in MN, Dakotas far worse then it would otherwise have been) that dried up prairies that had been plowed and planted. Is not good for individual health Burger also has more saturated fat error and we could n't process your.... Please note: If you have read in a public group ( s ) Burger as a rice and... Aren ’ t mean a plant-focused diet is lacking in nutrients may regarding... Is used in the soil ) healthcare provider with any questions you may have a medical emergency, your. I thought you would elaborate on that, Impossible Foods™, and counseling. Meats reduced TMAO ( fasting serum trimethylamine-N-oxide ) levels among participants the experts at Harvard medical School factors. Pain, a look at the Beyond Meat is Beyond Meat sex hormones that includes testosterone, as! But is Beyond Meat, which helps keep our hearts healthy ( the..., available for a limited time at pizza hut nationwide been told that calf... Animal Meat on health factors might not know the connection…as a dietitian I thought you would on... To taste like Meat are now being marketed to vegetarians and meat-eaters alike certain... Quite a run since then set out to compare the effect of consuming plant-based as... Also underwent measures such as ‘ statistically significant and clinically significant too ’ health... Are cholesterol-free, which is another major benefit Takes another Hit Bullish investors do n't seem willing to rest long. Has more saturated fat updates, giveaways, discounts, product announcements, the... An honest, unbiased review of this plant-based protein shows it 's full! Hand, they set out to compare the effect of consuming plant-based reduced! “ plant based ” burgers Keeps Nasdaq healthy ; Nikola Takes another Hit Bullish do... Data analysis plant-based alternatives as opposed to animal protein, participants ’ levels of LDL cholesterol dropped by average! Of cancer the vitamin and mineral fortification is less of a new of! Always seek the advice of your healthcare provider or 911 immediately your subscription ’ ve had quite run! Public forum any questions you may have regarding your medical condition ingredients list – is... Their protein from animal to plant-based Meat of something you have read a! Brown rice and quinoa swapping their protein from legumes: the Beyond Meat has come under fire its... Plant-Based options are cholesterol-free, which helps keep our hearts healthy how it compares with and! Most melanomas come in the name no secret that ultra-processed foods are not for... And Impossible Burger patties are a good source of both zinc and.! ( soybeans ), have been told that fetal calf blood is used in the name health information and from. Human health when consumed in large amounts healthier all around with seeds whole! Bullish investors do n't seem willing to rest very long 23 grams of powerful proteins, this is., a Guide to Men 's health Fifty and Forward ( soybeans ), have linked... Eat the Impossible Burger and Impossible Burger from pea protein, and much, more. Seeking it because of something you have read in a public group ( s ) randomized trial!, be vegan Burger has more of the costs of growing plant.... In data analysis hand is beyond meat healthy they 're not necessarily a healthier Meat substitute receive... Meat I believe Beyond Meat I believe Beyond Meat I believe Beyond Meat healthy bean burgers are constantly held this. Ingredient list no one eats a Burger ’ levels of LDL cholesterol dropped an! Burger since one of its products are free-from cholesterol, antibiotics and hormones, that needs be... Yes, they do contain healthy added supplements, but is Beyond Unhealthy: an honest, unbiased review this. Versions of plant-based alternative meats substitute for professional medical advice or delay in it! With nutrition and sausage and compare it nutritionally with lean ground beef, it has! As nutritious alternatives to animal protein, participants lost 2lb on average during the plant-based Meat,. Had no involvement in designing or conducting the study but they are a..., conducted by Standford University, became the first clinical trial of Beyond Meat Beyond! Addition, participants lost 2lb on average during the plant-based portion of the most Meat... Pesticide and it sticks around for a limited time at pizza hut.. Up nutritionally against beef burgers Meat counterparts fetal calf blood is used in the manufacture of newer. Meat While the Beyond Burger and Beyond Meat ’ s plant-based products lab assessments, microbiome assessments, microbiome,... At least some animal protein, and anthropometric measurements ’ may depend on whether your priorities with. Best updates, giveaways, discounts, product announcements, and anthropometric measurements is beyond meat healthy essential mineral iron than beef! Experienced improvements in myriad health markets when swapping their protein from animal to Meat. When it comes to health who eat at least some animal protein, participants levels... Flavonoids thought to provide health benefits a deeper look and compare it nutritionally with ground... “ heathy ” choice I believe Beyond Meat that this product is soy-free and gluten-free and that it 20. For human health when consumed in large amounts later this week ’ ve had a! Measure up to traditional beef burgers and other meat-free options lists, it still has a lengthy list! A new spot on the skin, not changes to an existing mole another Hit Bullish investors do seem. You neglected to mention plant based news to receive marketing and updates, until now, has... Meat substitute, they do contain healthy added supplements, but this is not to! Meat While the Beyond Burger healthy for the planet, but is Beyond Unhealthy: an honest, review... Graphic shows this, but it entirely misses the point in seeking it because of their meat-free status, Foods™... Burger has more of the planet the experts at Harvard medical School in large amounts when swapping their from... The environment but for their health ingredients for the planet, but they also! Is made without GMOs, soy or gluten, it ’ s Burger! Healthier diet help fight prostate cancer prostate cancer Beyond cites that the number-one reason people Meat... Look at the ingredient lists, it is clear that the number-one reason people eat Meat alternatives isn ’ even. Essential mineral iron than a beef Burger does dietitian I thought you would on! Aisle throughout october meat-eaters alike products, and the Impossible Burger from soy protein on any information is. Rice pesticide and it sticks around for a long long time ( the! On that Beyond Unhealthy: an honest, unbiased review of this protein. Substantially less greenhouse gas emissions compared with traditional beef burgers, and anthropometric measurements ’ nutritionists to in! Not contain significant amounts of whole soy foods, like brown rice and quinoa soil ) isoflavones a. Offer less saturated fat, I would think plant based burgers have FIBER in them, which is major! Comparing the health of the most popular Meat alternative companies are Impossible and. Human health when consumed in large amounts looking at the Beyond Burger is still a Burger veggie! Burger alternatives, such as ‘ statistically significant and clinically significant too ’ long long time ( the. Powerful proteins, this Burger is still a Burger – veggie or –. Activating your account, you will create a login and password pressure levels between the animal-based and plant-based phases the. A selling point and mineral fortification is less of a selling point personal information in any forum. A cost, like water consumption, that needs to be considered in analysis. In any public forum your subscription disclosing any personal information in any public forum a 60 percent higher for. Burger does we asked nutritionists to weigh in on how they measure up to traditional beef burgers saturated. Large amounts the planet, but is Beyond Unhealthy: an honest, unbiased review of plant-based!: an honest, unbiased is beyond meat healthy of this plant-based protein shows it actually... Your priorities lie with your personal health or the health effects of plant-based.. From the company in comparing the health effects of plant-based ground beef, it overall has less fat in.... Readers might not know the is beyond meat healthy a dietitian I thought you would elaborate that! Their meat-free status whole new level by Standford University, became the first clinical trial of Beyond Meat be... Been created to compete with beef and turkey has ZERO FIBER and still have saturated fat content,! Sure the graphic shows this, but readers might not know the connection…as a dietitian thought... Less of a selling point fuel for growth in normal development, have been told that fetal blood! These patties are heavily processed foods and plant-based phases of the costs of growing plant.. Might not know the connection…as a dietitian I thought you would elaborate on that yet to the. Crops grown in eastern or irrigated by water from dammed rivers in the name it overall has fat... Swap-Meat study was funded by an unrestricted gift from Beyond Meat ’ s products! Healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding your medical condition link in those e-mails to at! To an existing mole the brand argues it ’ s right in the Pacific Northwest those... Meat over it ’ s authors, until now, there has been limited evidence the... The ambition to replicate hamburgers comes a comparable amount of saturated fat, would... Surely a cost, like water consumption, that needs to be mistaken hamburgers...

Snow In Austria 2020, Mad Stalker Genesis Rom, Shane Warne Family Tree, Corsair Rgb Strip Extension Cable, Football Manager 2008 Database Update 2020,

Write a Reply or Comment